Particle.news

Download on the App Store

New York Times Adds Buried Note on Gazan Child’s Health, Faces Sustained Criticism

Critics contend that the buried update on the child’s medical history fails to address broader flaws in the Times’ image verification process.

Image
Image
Image

Overview

  • On August 4, the Times appended a buried editor’s note and updated its front-page story to acknowledge that 18-month-old Mohammed Zakariya al-Matouq had pre-existing health conditions including a muscle disorder.
  • The correction followed five days of pressure from the Israeli consulate in New York and media watchdog HonestReporting.
  • Internal communications obtained by Semafor indicate that top editors rejected images of children with pre-existing conditions yet still failed to source a suitable photo of a healthy child suffering malnutrition.
  • Algemeiner criticized the Times’ apology as insufficient and argued the misrepresented photo has been weaponized to vilify Israel on the international stage.
  • Former New York Times creative services editor Yaakov Ort publicly accused the paper of 'twisting' facts in its Israel-Hamas coverage and neglecting evidence of Israeli hostages’ suffering.