Overview
- A five-judge Appellate Division panel vacated roughly $464–$527 million in restitution and penalties, calling the sum an excessive fine under the Eighth Amendment.
- Judges left intact the lower court’s finding that Donald Trump, the Trump Organization, and his sons Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump committed civil fraud by inflating asset values.
- The decision came in a fractured 323-page set of opinions with no single majority, including a separate writing that accused the prosecution of political intent.
- Non-monetary measures, including limits on doing business in New York and temporary bans on corporate leadership, remain paused or under review as appeals continue.
- Trump hailed the outcome as a “total victory,” while the attorney general vowed to appeal to the New York Court of Appeals; Trump had posted a $175 million bond that stayed collection.