New Era Begins for David Hemingson with 'The Holdovers'; Reviews Mixed for Film Starring Giamatti and Randolph

Despite Positive Reception by Some Critics, Others Criticize 'The Holdovers' for Its Clunky Plot and Overused Tropes

Alexander Payne's latest film, 'The Holdovers', is set in a New England prep school in 1970, featuring Paul Giamatti as a curmudgeonly boarding school instructor who oversees five students over Christmas break.
Critics have praised Giamatti's portrayal of the character, with the New York Times noting his ability to bring depth and surprise to the role with a combination of crudeness, discourtesy, and bits of sweetness.
The film, written by David Hemingson, is based on his personal experiences of attending a New England prep school, and explores themes of class, inequality, privilege, and the sense of being an outsider.
Mixed reviews highlight the richness and nuance of the film while criticizing its underdeveloped characters and lack of emotional exploration, and pointing out the movie’s tendency towards using outdated cultural tropes.
Despite some negative reviews criticizing its predictability and overstatement, the film has been largely praised for its solid performances and nostalgic touch, transporting audiences back to the adventurous spirit of New Hollywood.