Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Netflix’s ‘The Abandons’ Draws Early Mixed Reviews After Dec. 4 Debut

Critics praise Gillian Anderson’s first villain role even as they fault the show’s writing, pacing and action clarity.

Overview

  • Netflix released the seven-episode Western on Dec. 4, starring Gillian Anderson and Lena Headey as rival widowed matriarchs in 1854 Washington Territory.
  • Initial reviews lean negative, with Newsday calling the series a misfire for lurching, incoherent writing, muddy action and indistinguishable supporting characters.
  • Anderson’s icy portrayal of Constance is widely highlighted as a standout, with coverage noting it is her first time playing a self-described “baddie.”
  • Other critiques focus on tone and performance, with The Observer describing a soapy feel and singling out Headey’s accent and characterization for inconsistency.
  • The story is fictional but draws on creator Kurt Sutter’s interest in the origins of La Cosa Nostra; Sutter later withdrew over creative differences and Otto Bathurst directed the seven-episode run.