Netflix’s 'American Primeval' Examines Brutality of the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre

The series blends historical events with fictionalized narratives, sparking discussions on its depiction of violence, colonization, and the Mormon Church's role in the massacre.

• 'American Primeval,' created by Mark L. Smith and directed by Peter Berg, dramatizes the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre in Utah Territory, blending historical events with fictional elements.
• The six-episode Netflix series explores themes of violence, survival, and human depravity during the American frontier, following a mother and son's perilous journey west.
• Critics praise the show’s gripping storytelling and production quality but highlight its historical inaccuracies, including exaggerated portrayals of violence and events.
• The series has reignited discussions about the Mormon Church's role in the massacre, which it historically sought to minimize, and the broader implications of religious and cultural conflicts of the era.
• While some applaud its visceral depiction of frontier brutality, others argue it misses an opportunity to explore the nuanced political and democratic struggles of the period.

4 Articles

The Salt Lake Tribune The Hollywood Reporter Religion Dispatches The Independent