Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Netflix Doc Puts Carman Family Tragedies Back in Focus as Legal Questions Linger

The film revives unresolved questions by presenting investigators' claims alongside family testimony without new legal findings.

Overview

  • The Carman Family Deaths premiered on Netflix on Nov. 19, revisiting the 2013 killing of John Chakalos and the 2016 disappearance of his daughter, Linda, during a fishing trip with her son, Nathan.
  • A Coast Guard search ended with Nathan found alone in a life raft eight days later, while Linda’s body was never recovered and she was declared dead in 2023.
  • A 2022 federal indictment charged Nathan with murdering his mother and alleged fraud tied to his grandfather’s death; he died by suicide in jail on June 15, 2023, and the charges were dismissed.
  • The documentary highlights investigative threads including an email Nathan sent about inheritance and a rifle he denied owning, alongside insurance filings that concluded his boat’s loss was caused intentionally after alterations.
  • People reports omissions from the film, including court claims about a much-younger girlfriend of John, a probate ‘slayer action’ by Nathan’s aunts to block inheritance for further investigation, and a note found in Nathan’s cell that his lawyer said was not a suicide note.