Particle.news
Download on the App Store

NASA Scientist Points to 5 BC Comet as Plausible Source of the Star of Bethlehem

Orbital modeling of a Chinese‑recorded object indicates a close Earth pass capable of reproducing Matthew’s described motion.

Overview

  • Mark Matney’s study, published in the Journal of the British Astronomical Association, analyzes a bright comet logged by Chinese court astronomers for more than 70 days in spring 5 BC.
  • Reconstructed trajectories place the object at roughly lunar distance—about 236,000 to 249,000 miles from Earth—yielding a temporary geosynchronous‑like effect that makes it appear to pause overhead.
  • One modeled scenario shows a June morning in 5 BC when, as seen from Judea, the comet aligned with the road from Jerusalem to Bethlehem before lingering near the zenith.
  • At that range the comet would have been exceptionally bright, possibly visible in daylight, with the 2014 Siding Spring flyby of Mars cited as evidence that such close approaches can occur.
  • The proposal is presented as plausible rather than conclusive, joining hundreds of prior explanations that include planetary conjunction and supernova theories.