Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Munich Court Rules ChatGPT Illegally Used Song Lyrics, Siding With GEMA

A first‑instance ruling imposes injunctions plus damages with disclosure obligations.

Overview

  • The Regional Court of Munich I found that OpenAI infringed German copyright by using nine song texts to train ChatGPT.
  • OpenAI must stop storing or outputting the specific lyrics, pay damages, and disclose how the works were used and any related revenues.
  • Judges held that both memorization within the models and near‑verbatim outputs constituted unlawful exploitation, rejecting OpenAI’s synthesis defense.
  • The judgment is not final, and OpenAI said it disagrees and will consider further steps, with an appeal and possible referral to the European Court of Justice expected.
  • A personality‑rights claim by GEMA was rejected, while legal experts and creator groups say the case could set terms for licensing across music, journalism, literature and visual media.