Particle.news

Moraes Votes to Receive PGR Complaint Against Marcel Van Hattem at STF

The vote tests whether Article 53 parliamentary immunity shields elected officials who publicly attack a federal police delegate’s honor, with the Primeira Turma set to decide in person.

Overview

  • The Prosecutor General filed a criminal complaint accusing deputy Marcel Van Hattem of calúnia and injúria for public claims that PF delegate Fábio Shor fabricated investigative reports tied to Filipe Martins.
  • Relator Flávio Dino and Minister Alexandre de Moraes have voted to receive the PGR complaint, with Moraes saying Van Hattem’s statements exceeded parliamentary immunity and amounted to personal attacks.
  • The virtual judgment was removed after a request by Minister Cristiano Zanin and will be concluded in an unscheduled, in-person session of the Primeira Turma of the STF where the remaining votes of Zanin and Cármen Lúcia will decide if Van Hattem becomes a formal defendant.
  • Van Hattem’s defense argues his remarks were based on factual evidence, citing a contested U.S. entry record for Filipe Martins, and says Article 53 protects speech by lawmakers; acceptance of the complaint would open a criminal process in which he can present that evidence.
  • Legal observers and the association Lexum have criticized the Court’s handling, arguing the decision narrows immunity in a way that could chill parliamentary oversight and raising questions about impartiality because of reported ties between the targeted delegate and Minister Moraes’s office.