Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Modern Orthodox Rabbis' Gaza Letter, Condemning Hamas and Urging Aid, Draws Right-Leaning Backlash

Right-leaning critics say the appeal over hunger in Gaza adopts Hamas narratives.

Overview

  • The coalition of more than 80 Modern Orthodox rabbis, led by Rabbi Yosef Blau, issued a statement condemning Hamas and urging Israel to prevent mass starvation in Gaza.
  • The letter also denounces extremist settler violence in the West Bank and warns against blanket suspicion of Gazan civilians.
  • Notable signatories include the head of Yeshivat Maale Gilboa and the chief rabbis of Poland, Denmark and Norway, along with senior rabbis of prominent U.S. congregations.
  • Israel National News and other right-leaning commentators criticized the statement as echoing Hamas propaganda, disputing claims of mass starvation and citing a COGAT review alleging inflated hunger-related death counts.
  • Signatory Rabbi David Bigman clarified that the statement does not accuse Israel of causing the crisis or call for ending the war, emphasizing a call for responsible humanitarian action.