Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Modern Orthodox Rabbis' Gaza Letter, Condemning Hamas and Urging Aid, Draws Right-Leaning Backlash

Right-leaning critics say the appeal over hunger in Gaza adopts Hamas narratives.

Gazans flock to the area where humanitarian aid is dropped from the air in Deir al Balah on Aug. 19, 2025. (Mohammed Nassar/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Israel National News

Overview

  • The coalition of more than 80 Modern Orthodox rabbis, led by Rabbi Yosef Blau, issued a statement condemning Hamas and urging Israel to prevent mass starvation in Gaza.
  • The letter also denounces extremist settler violence in the West Bank and warns against blanket suspicion of Gazan civilians.
  • Notable signatories include the head of Yeshivat Maale Gilboa and the chief rabbis of Poland, Denmark and Norway, along with senior rabbis of prominent U.S. congregations.
  • Israel National News and other right-leaning commentators criticized the statement as echoing Hamas propaganda, disputing claims of mass starvation and citing a COGAT review alleging inflated hunger-related death counts.
  • Signatory Rabbi David Bigman clarified that the statement does not accuse Israel of causing the crisis or call for ending the war, emphasizing a call for responsible humanitarian action.