Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Mexico’s Supreme Court Sets First Public Hearing on Disability Consultation Rule

The justices paused a Michoacán case to hear affected voices before deciding whether to replace automatic nullification for lack of prior consultation with case-by-case review.

Overview

  • The SCJN will hold its first public hearing on October 20 at 12:00 under General Agreement 5/2025 to receive testimony from persons with disabilities and civil society.
  • Minister President Hugo Aguilar Ortiz announced the unanimous Pleno decision after demonstrators delivered an open letter outside the Court.
  • The hearing relates to action of unconstitutionality 182/2024 against a Michoacán law, and Minister Lenia Batres withdrew her draft from immediate vote to allow the session.
  • Batres’s project proposes ending automatic invalidation for lack of prior consultation, arguing for substantive rights analysis, whereas earlier jurisprudence struck down more than 50 laws on procedural grounds.
  • Disability organizations and Human Rights Watch warn that changing the standard would weaken protections and shift litigation burdens onto people who often lack standing or face structural barriers.