Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Meta-analysis finds Apple Watch accurate on heart rate and steps but misestimates calories burned

A University of Mississippi analysis documents that calorie readings can err by nearly 28 percent on Apple Watch devices

Trust the heart rate and steps metrics, but be skeptical about the calories.
Image

Overview

  • Researchers reviewed 56 studies comparing Apple Watch metrics against gold-standard clinical tools to assess accuracy across multiple device models.
  • Heart rate tracking showed a mean absolute error of 4.43 percent and step counting erred by 8.17 percent, both within consumer-grade “excellent” thresholds.
  • Energy expenditure estimates averaged a 27.96 percent error rate, far exceeding acceptable margins for reliable calorie tracking.
  • Newer Apple Watch models demonstrated gradual improvements in both hardware and algorithms, yielding better accuracy over earlier generations.
  • Investigators recommend using the device as a motivational aid rather than a clinical diagnostic tool given its measurement limitations.