Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Massachusetts Man Arrested for 2003 Milford Father’s Cold Case Murder

He remains held without bail ahead of arraignment in Essex County Superior Court before extradition to New Hampshire.

Michael Carlisle leaving Wrentham District Court after being arraigned on charges including child pornography on Tuesday, June 17, 2025.

Overview

  • Douglas Herlihy, 39, was taken into custody Tuesday in Saugus, Massachusetts, under a warrant charging him with second-degree murder.
  • Authorities say Paul Herlihy, 50, died from blunt force trauma and was found in his Milford home during a welfare check in August 2003.
  • Herlihy was initially arrested at age 17 a day after his father’s body was discovered but was never charged in the killing.
  • New Hampshire Attorney General John Formella’s office has declined to disclose what new evidence prompted charges after more than two decades.
  • After his expected arraignment in Essex County Superior Court, Herlihy will be extradited to New Hampshire to face the murder charge