Particle.news

Man Sentenced to Two Consecutive Life Terms for 2005 Potrero Hill Killings

A judge imposed back-to-back life-without-parole sentences after a retrial prosecutors say restored accountability in a case once tossed for juror racial bias.

Overview

  • The sentence was handed down Thursday, when Judge Michael McNaughton ordered two consecutive life terms without parole to be followed by additional 25-to-life terms for each murder.
  • Joseph Stevens was convicted at a retrial in December 2025 of two counts of first-degree murder with special circumstances and of assault with a firearm for the 2005 attack.
  • Prosecutors say Stevens fired 18 shots on Oct. 14, 2005 into a parked vehicle in Potrero Hill, killing 22-year-old Dernae Wysinger and his 2-year-old son Naemon and wounding the boy’s mother, Jazmanika Ridout.
  • Stevens’ earlier 2007 conviction was overturned by a federal court in 2018 after lawyers proved a juror had been racially biased, which led to the retrial and renewed testimony that the district attorney said retraumatized the family.
  • The judge said he ran the sentences consecutively to "respect the dignity of each life," and prosecutors and advocates say the outcome highlights tensions between appellate review, juror fairness, and the long emotional toll on victims’ families.