Overview

• Evans entered the U.S. legally in September 2023 but overstayed his visa and was later cleared by E-Verify in May to work as a seasonal reserve officer.
• On July 25, his attempt to buy a firearm triggered an ATF alert and led to his arrest by ICE for unlawful presence.
• Old Orchard Beach officials say they compiled extensive background materials—including ID copies, driving and education records, and personal references—to vet Evans before hiring him.
• DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin insisted that E-Verify approvals do not replace employers’ obligation to confirm the authenticity of work documents.
• Legal experts warn that E-Verify cannot verify document authenticity or reveal a worker’s true immigration status, highlighting gaps in the federal system.