Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Mafia: The Old Country Delivers Stunning Sicily but Stumbles on Linear Gameplay

Critics say the game's focused, cinematic approach highlights a compelling sense of place, sacrificing freedom for a controlled narrative.

Image
Image
blank
Image

Overview

  • Reviewers praise the game’s visual and audio presentation, citing detailed period environments, immersive sound design and standout voice performances powered by Unreal Engine 5.
  • Enzo Favara’s slow-burn narrative and strong character work receive acclaim for grounding players in early 1900s Sicily before the story’s violence intensifies.
  • Critics fault the restrictive mission markers and limited exploration, noting that straying from objectives often triggers instant failure.
  • Combat and stealth mechanics draw criticism for feeling dated and repetitive, with imprecise shooting and insta-fail sneaking sequences diminishing player engagement.
  • Early Metacritic scores hover around 76, reflecting a mixed-to-positive consensus that skews toward established fans while suggesting casual players may prefer to wait for discounts.