Particle.news

Lula Loses Case Against Journalist Over 'Devil' Video, Ordered to Pay R$9,395

A Brasília judge ruled the rhetoric was protected opinion under freedom of expression.

Overview

  • The TJ-DFT's 11th Civil Court rejected President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's civil action and request to remove the YouTube video.
  • Judge Paulo Cerqueira Campos found that Luís Ernesto Lacombe used religious metaphor to criticize government policies rather than to injure or defame.
  • The decision, signed on February 19, obliges Lula to pay R$9,395 in court costs and the journalist's attorney fees.
  • The Advocacia-Geral da União argued the video constituted offensive speech that harmed the president's dignity and could amount to injúria.
  • The Ministério Público Federal had previously recommended archiving the inquiry as political criticism, and Lula may still appeal the ruling.