Overview
- In a Podcrushed interview with Penn Badgley, Caplan says the audition was very long and she was determined to join the film after finding the script exceptionally funny.
- She says studio decisionmakers initially resisted casting her and considered Kelly Osbourne for Janis Ian.
- To bolster her case, a Canadian hairstylist helped her try dark wigs on Hollywood Boulevard and send screen grabs that matched Janis’s goth aesthetic.
- Caplan recalls that auditioners first read for the two lead roles before casting sorted them into callback groups.
- She remembers a three‑month shoot in Toronto that felt like a dorm and says she bonded closely with Daniel Franzese and Jonathan Bennett.