Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Lily Allen Brings Dakota Johnson to SNL as “Madeline,” Prompting Online Backlash Over Vocals

The surprise casting sharpened focus on a confessional album born of her separation, with viewers divided between criticizing her delivery and blaming the live mix.

Overview

  • Allen performed “Sleepwalking” and “Madeline” from West End Girl in her second Saturday Night Live appearance since 2007.
  • Dakota Johnson portrayed the titular figure in “Madeline,” delivering the spoken-word passage from behind a screen before revealing herself and kissing Allen on the cheek.
  • Allen muted explicit lyrics during both songs to meet broadcast standards, avoiding profanities referenced on the studio recordings.
  • Real-time reactions on X skewed critical of her vocals and stage presence, while others argued technical mixing issues or nerves likely affected the sound.
  • The performance renewed attention on West End Girl’s themes tied to her separation from David Harbour and ongoing speculation around ‘Madeline,’ which Allen has described as a composite character, as tour plans continue.