Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Leaked Memo Exposes Flaws in BBC Verify Insurance Report Removed for Breaching Standards

A memo from former standards adviser Michael Prescott describes data flaws, selective sourcing, editorial failings behind the removed piece.

Overview

  • The BBC took down its car insurance article and posted a notice saying it did not meet normal editorial standards.
  • Prescott’s leaked memo called the Verify story “thoroughly wrong” and said an internal review he requested found multiple serious editorial problems.
  • The analysis reportedly relied on data at least five years old and failed to control for key pricing factors such as local claims history and uninsured driving.
  • The Association of British Insurers provided contextual information that was reportedly quoted selectively in the BBC coverage.
  • Reports say no staff have been disciplined, the BBC is not commenting on the leak, and political critics have called for accountability.