Overview
- The Landmarks Preservation Commission took public testimony Dec. 9 on West Park Presbyterian’s request to lift landmark status on its 135- to 140-year-old church.
- An LPC member said the case will return in early 2026 for further questions and a potential vote after additional consideration.
- Church leaders argue the structure is severely deteriorated and repairs are unaffordable, and they have a near $50 million sale contract with a developer to replace it with housing and a 10,000-square-foot worship and community space.
- Preservationists, the evicted Center at West Park, artists, celebrities, and elected officials urged denial, with the arts group offering $30,000 per month in rent and fundraising help for repairs.
- The decision carries high stakes as hardship exemptions are rare—13 granted in 57 years—with approval potentially allowing demolition and new development next year, and denial requiring the congregation to retain the building.