Overview
- Chief Justice Nitin Jamdar and Justice Basant Balaji dismissed the petition on October 13.
- The PIL by advocate Rajasimhan sought to halt sales of 'Mother Mary Comes To Me' over a cover photo showing Roy smoking without statutory warnings.
- The court recorded Penguin Random House India's statement that the back cover carries a disclaimer stating the image is representational and does not endorse tobacco use.
- The judges criticized the petitioner for bypassing the COTPA mechanism, failing to verify facts, and not reading the entire book, cautioning against misuse of PILs.
- The matter is recorded as Rajasimhan v. Union of India, WP (PIL) No. 117/2025, and a detailed written order is awaited with the petitioner free to approach the Steering Committee.