Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Kasich, MSNBC Analyst Clash On-Air Over Whether Urban Crime Is a ‘Manufactured Crisis’

The segment contrasted a call for a tightly scoped federal role with a case that community efforts undercut crisis claims.

Overview

  • On Chris Jansing Reports, former Ohio governor and MSNBC contributor John Kasich argued that urban violence is not manufactured and said people are at risk.
  • Kasich pointed to personal experiences in Chicago and Baltimore to claim some neighborhoods feel unsafe.
  • He said any federal involvement should have a narrowly defined mission and clearly articulated legal authority.
  • MSNBC analyst Basil Smilke countered that high rents and strong demand for city living contradict crisis narratives and highlighted resident–police partnerships and nonprofit violence interrupter programs.
  • Smilke criticized the president’s described approach as deploying heavily armed officers in largely Black-led cities, and no new federal policy or deployment was reported.