Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Karine Silva’s Unanimous Decision Victory Over Dione Barbosa Draws Backlash

Judges’ scoring came under fire after all three officials awarded Silva the last two rounds despite Barbosa’s strong start.

Image

Overview

  • Karine Silva avenged her 2019 regional defeat by beating Dione Barbosa by unanimous decision with three 29-28 scorecards.
  • The United Center crowd booed the outcome and UFC commentators Joe Rogan and Daniel Cormier publicly condemned the judges’ rulings.
  • All three judges scored rounds two and three for Silva even though Barbosa dominated the opening stanza and nearly secured a first-round armbar.
  • Dione Barbosa stepped in on short notice after JJ Aldrich withdrew due to injury, a factor noted in assessing expectations for the bout.
  • Daniel Cormier called for an overhaul of MMA judging standards and Silva defended her win by pointing to multiple near-finishes in the later rounds.