Overview

• Susie Evans surprised contestants with her arrival in Episode 2 on the Costa Rica beach, reigniting interest in her history with Justin Glaze.
• Lexi Young paused her connection with Justin, expressing worry that he was still processing their breakup just months earlier.
• During the rose ceremony, Justin handed his rose to Susie instead of Lexi, catching fellow contestants off guard.
• Susie tearfully declined the rose and Justin abruptly walked out of the ceremony, ending the night on a dramatic cliffhanger.
• Hannah Brown admitted she hoped the exes would reunite on the beach and Wells Adams questioned if Justin was truly over Susie, fueling fan speculation.