Overview

• An Arapahoe County jury found Jonathan Muniz, 33, guilty of robbery, felony theft, conspiracy to commit felony theft and third-degree assault after a three-day trial.
• Investigators said Timothy Davis pretended to have a seizure inside Perfect Pets on Feb. 21, 2025, as Muniz grabbed two English Bulldog puppies and assaulted employees while fleeing.
• Sentencing for Muniz is set for Dec. 5, according to the Arapahoe County Sheriff's Office.
• Cases against two co-defendants remain pending, with Porfiria Tacorante scheduled for arraignment on Oct. 24.
• One stolen puppy was returned by a buyer who recognized it from news coverage, while the second remains missing; each was valued at more than $4,200.