Overview
- A New Mexico judge vacated the four-count grand-jury indictment against Timothy Busfield on Friday after concluding prosecutors acted unfairly in the grand-jury process.
- The judge’s six-page order says prosecutors gave jurors incorrect instructions about subpoenas and effectively prevented jurors from hearing witnesses who were described as present and ready to testify.
- Defense lawyers played recordings from a September 25 hearing in which jurors asked to hear more witnesses and were told subpoenas were required despite the defense saying those witnesses were available.
- The underlying allegations stem from a January criminal complaint by the parents of two twin boys who appeared on The Cleaning Lady; Busfield has denied the claims and said the case cost him work and his agency representation.
- The vacatur removes the current charges but is not an acquittal because the district attorney’s office is reviewing the order and may correct the defects and seek a new prosecution, a step that would reopen legal uncertainty and prolong damage to reputations.