Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Judge Sets May 18 Ruling on Evidence After Mangione Suppression Hearing Ends

The decision will determine whether jurors see key items seized in Pennsylvania, including a 9 mm handgun, a silencer, plus a red notebook.

Overview

  • Both sides rested after a nine-day hearing focused on Altoona police questioning and a backpack search during Luigi Mangione’s Dec. 9, 2024 arrest.
  • Judge Gregory Carro set a schedule for written submissions with the defense due Jan. 29 and prosecutors due March 5, with a defense reply two weeks later.
  • Prosecutors presented body-worn camera video, 911 audio and photos while calling roughly 17–20 witnesses; the defense called no witnesses.
  • The Manhattan district attorney’s office said it will not use certain station-house statements, while arguing the backpack search was lawful as incident to arrest and later supported by a warrant.
  • A separate federal proceeding remains pending, with an admissibility hearing set for Jan. 9 and prosecutors indicating they will seek the death penalty.