Overview
- A D.C. Superior Court judge dismissed the felony indictment against David Hearn with prejudice on Oct. 1, blocking prosecutors from recharging him and citing the realistic risk of politically driven reprosecution.
- Prosecutors moved to drop the case in July after Interior and contractor records showed the pool’s liner failed from a rushed, flawed installation, not from vandalism.
- Hearn was detained on June 19 after he touched a loose piece of the new liner and was later indicted on July 2, but he says he never tore or removed the material and was held for about five hours without a phone call or Miranda warnings.
- Hearn’s lawyers allege the Justice Department had exculpatory materials before the indictment, point to a June 30 damage assessment documenting earlier liner failures, and accuse prosecutors of mishandling evidence and improperly approaching a defense expert.
- On Oct. 6 Hearn’s legal team formally asked the DOJ and Interior inspectors general to open coordinated probes into the arrest, the prosecution decisions, evidence handling and Interior’s oversight, with civil suits and congressional review likely next steps.