Overview
- Chief Judge James Boasberg certified a class and found that 137 Venezuelan men deported to El Salvador were denied notice and a chance to contest their designation under the Alien Enemies Act.
- The administration must file by Jan. 5, 2026 a plan to either facilitate the men’s return to the United States or provide hearings abroad that satisfy due process.
- Boasberg concluded U.S. courts have jurisdiction because El Salvador held the men at the U.S.’s behest and with U.S. funding, establishing constructive custody.
- The dispute traces to March deportation flights that proceeded to CECOT despite an oral order to turn them back, with many detainees later sent to Venezuela in a July prisoner swap.
- A federal appeals panel has stayed Boasberg’s contemplated contempt proceedings over the March flights, and the administration maintains the men were outside U.S. custody and court reach.