J.J. McCarthy's NFL Draft Prospects Debated as Decision Looms

Despite leading Michigan to a national championship, questions remain about McCarthy's build and arm strength.

Mel Kiper Jr. ranks Michael Penix Jr. as the fourth-best quarterback for the 2024 NFL Draft, one spot ahead of J.J. McCarthy.
J.J. McCarthy, despite leading Michigan to a national championship, has been criticized for his slight build and lack of elite arm strength.
McCarthy is expected to make a decision about entering the 2024 NFL Draft in the coming days.
McCarthy's performance has been praised for his poise, high IQ, and arm talent, despite not having standout statistics.
McCarthy has a 26-1 record as a starter and has been praised as the best quarterback in Michigan's program history.