Overview
- Jessi Ngatikaura said on Instagram that the long-teased 'Fruity Pebbles' refers to Bret Engemann drinking Demi Engemann's urine, a claim not previously stated on the show.
- Demi responded that the act was a one-time, consensual, private experience in her marriage and said she shared the detail with Jessi in confidence nearly two years ago.
- Demi accused Jessi of airing the claim now to divert attention from Jessi's own affair becoming public, framing the disclosure as a breach of trust.
- The clash followed Demi's insinuation that the series is scripted, which Jessi rejected by saying, 'just because you script yourself doesn't mean our show is scripted.'
- The feud escalated through barbed comments and has renewed attention to the series, which is streaming on Hulu with a new season slated for early 2026.