Overview
- Plemons says he was "pretty shocked" when he learned his character would be at the center of a season 2 murder storyline.
- He recalls filming multiple versions of the pivotal scene and reshooting it to use a pipe after testing other props.
- The actor describes focusing on keeping the material believable, worrying about "not sinking the show" given its grounded tone.
- Coverage notes the arc drew backlash from viewers and critics and was largely abandoned by the following season.
- Plemons credits the series with inspiring his craft, calling it his first major role and praising the creative freedom it afforded.