Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Jen Pawol Returns to Minors as Debut Accuracy Draws Scrutiny

Umpire Scorecards metrics frame her debut as solid despite falling slightly short of the season average.

Overview

  • Pawol called 140 of 151 taken pitches correctly for a 92.72 percent accuracy on Aug. 10, compared with a 94.23 percent season average for MLB umpires.
  • Marlins manager Clayton McCullough praised her composure and game management after her first home-plate assignment, noting there were no ejections or on-field disputes.
  • Social-media and fan reactions varied widely, with some critics focusing on a handful of missed calls and others underscoring the statistical limits of evaluating a single game.
  • A former Hofstra catcher, Pawol spent 10 seasons and more than 1,200 games in the minors before serving as a AAA ‘rover,’ and she has returned to Class AAA with no new MLB date set.
  • This season’s 17 fill-in umpires have posted a median accuracy of about 94.5 percent over 189 games, highlighting the data-driven scrutiny all prospective MLB arbiters face.