Overview
- Chisholm finished the 2026 season with a .221 batting average, 18 home runs, 52 RBIs and 35 stolen bases, a slide from his earlier 30-30 peak that weakened his free-agent leverage.
- Insiders and reporters say the Yankees have not made a final decision on his offseason status, and the club is weighing roster flexibility, payroll and concerns about his increased strikeout rate.
- MLB.com's Mark Feinsand reported the Yankees could still extend a qualifying offer and that Chisholm might consider accepting a one-year return given his down year.
- Broadcaster Michael Kay and other commentators have criticized Chisholm's inconsistent hitting while also noting his youth, power and elite baserunning as reasons some in New York want to keep him.
- A qualifying offer is a single-year guaranteed deal that would attach draft-pick compensation if declined, a move that could give Chisholm a low-risk chance to rebuild value and give the Yankees time to resolve long-term roster choices.