Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Jay Roach’s War of the Roses Remake Draws Split Early Reviews

Early reviews in France point to a gentler take than Danny DeVito’s 1989 original.

Image
Olivia Colman et Benedict Cumbertach se livrent à un cabotinage british à côté de leurs pompes.
Olivia Colman et Benedict Cumberbatch dans <em>La Guere des Rose</em>, comédie noire de Jay Roach.
Image

Overview

  • The new film, written by Tony McNamara and starring Olivia Colman and Benedict Cumberbatch, reimagines the story with British leads in a Northern California setting for Searchlight.
  • Colman and Roach say they aimed for a more naturalistic, humane tone that balances humor with emotion rather than replicating the original’s caustic edge.
  • Le Parisien gives the remake 3 out of 5, praising lively dialogue while calling it “désespérément gentil” compared with the 1989 film.
  • Libération denounces the update as “aseptisé” and alleges “misogynie crasse,” positioning it against the first film’s darker, feminist reputation.
  • Sud Ouest describes a polished, fairly sombre satire that dissects shifting ambitions within the couple, and Roach notes Danny DeVito had not yet seen the remake during promotion.