Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Jackson’s Solo Dissents Deepen Tensions on Supreme Court

Justice Barrett’s rare rebuke highlights sharp disagreement over executive power limits

Overview

  • Jackson spoke 50% more words at oral arguments this term than any colleague and wrote more opinions than all but Justice Clarence Thomas
  • She issued a blistering solo dissent in the Trump birthright citizenship case warning of an existential threat to the rule of law
  • In a recent disability-benefits ruling, Jackson criticized her conservative colleagues’ “pure textualism” as manipulable to secure favorable outcomes
  • Her solo dissents in air pollution and Department of Government Efficiency data-access cases emphasized real-world impacts on ordinary citizens
  • Justice Amy Coney Barrett publicly lambasted Jackson’s birthright citizenship critique as inconsistent with centuries of precedent, underscoring deep methodological divides