Particle.news

High Court Restores Compensation Path for Sydney CBD Traders Over Light‑Rail Disruption

Judges found Transport for NSW failed to reasonably minimise substantial interference caused by the George Street project.

Overview

  • The High Court overturned a 2024 NSW Court of Appeal ruling that had removed liability for disruption from the Sydney light‑rail works.
  • The court held there was substantial interference with businesses’ use of their land and that Transport for NSW did not reasonably minimise it in planning and procurement.
  • Roughly 300 CBD businesses along the corridor can now pursue compensation claims over construction impacts such as noise, dust and prolonged access restrictions.
  • Earlier trial awards to Hunt Leather ($3,693,164) and Ancio Investments ($317,773) were set aside on appeal before this decision restored the traders’ cause of action.
  • The court confirmed litigation‑funder commissions cannot be added to damages, meaning any recoveries will face a reported 40% fee, against the backdrop of a project that ran from 2016 to 2020 with costs rising from about $1.6 billion to roughly $3 billion.