Particle.news

Download on the App Store

High Court Ends Roberts‑Smith Defamation Battle After Bid for Appeal Fails

The refusal leaves the Federal Court’s civil findings intact, with a costs sum to be set by negotiation.

Overview

  • Australia’s High Court refused special leave to appeal, closing seven years of litigation and leaving civil findings that Ben Roberts‑Smith was complicit in four unlawful killings in Afghanistan.
  • The court ordered Roberts‑Smith to pay Nine a negotiated lump‑sum contribution to appeal costs after rejecting indemnity costs, with a registrar to determine the amount if talks fail.
  • The Full Court’s reasoning highlighted three eyewitnesses to the Whiskey 108 killing and said the conduct described in the findings was not ambiguous.
  • The case featured a 110‑day trial with 41 witnesses and legal bills reported around $30 million plus additional appeal costs, with Kerry Stokes funding the trial but not the appeal.
  • Nine has subpoenaed Gina Rinehart for documents on any funding of Roberts‑Smith’s appeal as questions persist over who underwrote his costs, including a $910,000 security payment.