Particle.news
Download on the App Store

High Court Converts Permanent Pay Cut to Temporary in 25-Year Hisar Police Dog Case

The court applied proportionality to find a permanent stoppage of increments excessive for a delayed report of a missing service dog.

Overview

  • Justice Jagmohan Bansal on December 24 modified Head Constable Jagmal Singh’s penalty from forfeiture of two increments with permanent effect to forfeiture of two increments with temporary effect.
  • The case arose from Laika, a Hisar CID Dog Squad canine, slipping out during a neighbourhood wedding in June 2000 and being recovered about a month later.
  • A departmental inquiry did not hold Singh responsible for the escape but faulted him for not informing superiors at the earliest.
  • The disciplinary authority had initially ordered forfeiture of five increments with permanent effect, which the appellate authority reduced to two increments with permanent effect before the court’s intervention.
  • The court cited proportionality precedents, recorded that the kennel man in direct custody faced no action, found the earlier orders mechanical, and declined remand due to the protracted delay.