Helen Pitcher Resigns From Criminal Cases Review Commission After Criticism Over Malkinson Case

The former chair faces widespread calls to step down from her role at the Judicial Appointments Commission, citing eroded confidence in her leadership.

Helen Pitcher resigned as chair of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) following an independent panel's conclusion that she was unfit to lead.
Her handling of the Andrew Malkinson case, in which a man was wrongfully imprisoned for 17 years, drew sharp criticism for missed opportunities and lack of accountability.
Pitcher claims she was scapegoated for issues predating her tenure, but critics argue her leadership failed to address systemic flaws in the CCRC.
Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood and other officials have publicly stated that Pitcher’s judgment undermined confidence in the judicial system.
Calls have intensified for broader reform at the CCRC, including the resignation of senior leadership, to restore public trust and improve its effectiveness.