Overview
- The Center for Education Policy Research released a national, student-level analysis on Tuesday showing schools that required students to store phones in lockable pouches had annual gains of about 0.01 standard deviations, equal to roughly one to two weeks of learning per year.
- The study used NWEA MAP Growth scores for about 3.3 million students in grades 3–10 from 4,600 schools across 49 states and the District of Columbia to compare growth before and after pouch-based bans.
- Gains were steady across elementary, middle and high schools and across poverty and prior-achievement groups, and the bans also reduced the share of students experiencing large drops in reading scores.
- Authors and external researchers warn the effects are small and sensitive to methods because enforcement varies, students sometimes evade rules, state-level trends may confound results, and an earlier NBER study found near-zero impacts on scores.
- The paper highlights policy choices: many states now restrict phones, pouch systems cost about $25–$30 per student, and researchers urge using data from the recent Meta settlement to link out-of-school social‑media use to academic and mental‑health outcomes.