Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Guilty Pleas in 2012 Corey Stingley Death Lead to Deferred Prosecution

Prosecutors chose a restorative justice route shaped by meetings with the Stingley family, with a six-month review set to consider dismissal.

Overview

  • Robert Berringer, 67, and Jesse Cole, 39, pleaded guilty to felony murder tied to false imprisonment in the 2012 West Allis case.
  • Both men entered six-month deferred prosecutions that require community service, $500 charitable donations, and no new offenses.
  • They were released on $500 signature bonds, and prosecutors said they will seek dismissal with prejudice and expungement if terms are met.
  • The resolution followed a year of restorative sessions facilitated by former Judge Mary Triggiano at Marquette Law School’s Andrew Center for Restorative Justice.
  • Prosecutors cited the death of the most culpable participant and the family’s goals as reasons to avoid traditional sentencing that could have carried up to 18 years.