Overview
- District Judge Briony Clarke acquitted Linehan of harassing activist Sophia (also reported as Sonia) Brooks over posts made between 11 and 27 October 2024.
- She found him guilty of criminal damage after video showed he seized and threw Brooks’ phone outside the Battle of Ideas conference on 19 October 2024.
- The court imposed a £500 fine, £650 in costs and a £200 surcharge, declined a restraining order, and said the offense was not a hate crime though aggravated by Brooks being 17.
- In her judgment, Clarke deemed Linehan generally credible and said Brooks was not as alarmed or distressed as claimed, noting he rarely tagged her in the posts.
- Prosecutors argued his online comments were repeated and abusive, while the judge emphasized the court’s role was to apply the law rather than take a side in broader gender debates.