Particle.news

Fourth Circuit Lets Maryland Regulate Kalshi While Courts Divide Over Preemption

The fractured appellate decision raises the odds the Supreme Court will settle whether federal commodities law bars states from policing prediction-market betting.

Overview

  • A three-judge Fourth Circuit panel on Wednesday affirmed a lower court order letting Maryland enforce its sports-wagering laws against Kalshi in a 2-1 per curiam judgment that produced two concurring opinions and one dissent.
  • The concurrences reached the same result for different reasons: one judge said Kalshi had not shown Congress clearly displaced state gambling authority even if contracts are “swaps,” and another found the contracts are not swaps; the dissent argued the contracts are swaps and federally preempted.
  • A federal judge returned New York’s $36 billion enforcement suit to state court after concluding federal courts lacked subject-matter jurisdiction, and Kalshi filed emergency letters asking the Manhattan Supreme Court not to issue any ex parte restraining order without a hearing.
  • The Commodity Futures Trading Commission issued an emergency order in August directing Kalshi to keep operating and has sought to block state enforcement actions, a clash the company says could force liquidation of open positions or a nationwide shutdown if New York obtains broad restraints.
  • The rulings deepen a circuit split — with the 3rd Circuit siding with Kalshi and the 6th, 9th and now 4th siding against it on different grounds — increasing the chance the Supreme Court must decide whether event contracts traded on Kalshi are CEA-defined “swaps” that preempt state gambling laws.