Overview
- A three-judge Fourth Circuit panel on Wednesday affirmed a lower court order letting Maryland enforce its sports-wagering laws against Kalshi in a 2-1 per curiam judgment that produced two concurring opinions and one dissent.
- The concurrences reached the same result for different reasons: one judge said Kalshi had not shown Congress clearly displaced state gambling authority even if contracts are “swaps,” and another found the contracts are not swaps; the dissent argued the contracts are swaps and federally preempted.
- A federal judge returned New York’s $36 billion enforcement suit to state court after concluding federal courts lacked subject-matter jurisdiction, and Kalshi filed emergency letters asking the Manhattan Supreme Court not to issue any ex parte restraining order without a hearing.
- The Commodity Futures Trading Commission issued an emergency order in August directing Kalshi to keep operating and has sought to block state enforcement actions, a clash the company says could force liquidation of open positions or a nationwide shutdown if New York obtains broad restraints.
- The rulings deepen a circuit split — with the 3rd Circuit siding with Kalshi and the 6th, 9th and now 4th siding against it on different grounds — increasing the chance the Supreme Court must decide whether event contracts traded on Kalshi are CEA-defined “swaps” that preempt state gambling laws.