Overview
- The Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which ruled Thursday, rejected the administration’s request to re-detain Badar Khan Suri and declined to transfer his case from Virginia to Texas.
- The court held that federal immigration law does not bar a district judge from hearing Suri’s habeas claim that his March 2025 arrest violated his due process and First Amendment rights.
- A Virginia district judge had ordered Suri released in May 2025 after finding he was likely to show his arrest was retaliation for protected speech, and the appeals panel affirmed that relief while his immigration case continues.
- The government had argued district courts must defer to the DOJ-run immigration courts and that removal proceedings should be the first forum, but the Fourth Circuit said denying immediate review would make constitutional claims effectively unreviewable.
- The decision deepens a split with the Second and Third Circuits, which recently reversed similar district-court releases, and that division increases the likelihood the Supreme Court will weigh in on the scope of habeas and speech protections for noncitizens.