Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Forty Years After Argentina's Junta Trial, Reflections on Justice and Its Limits

New retrospectives question how early convictions failed to cement a shared rule-of-law consensus.

Overview

  • The anniversary highlights Dec. 9, 1985, when Argentina’s Federal Chamber convicted five ex-commanders after more than 500 hours of testimony from over 800 witnesses.
  • Architects Carlos Nino and Jaime Malamud Goti advanced the plan in 1982, followed by President Raúl Alfonsín’s decrees and the creation of CONADEP that enabled the prosecutions.
  • The ruling directed courts nationwide to pursue related cases, yielding roughly 400 accused or convicted by the end of Alfonsín’s term as prosecutors and judges worked under credible threats.
  • Carapintada uprisings preceded Congress passing Punto Final and Obediencia Debida, which did not vacate the junta convictions, while President Carlos Menem’s pardons later freed many military leaders.
  • To protect the record, appellate judges secretly duplicated 530 hours of hearings and stored them in Oslo, and subsequent reopenings during the Kirchner years drew criticism for politicization and for decades-long cases without final sentences.