Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Former Supreme Court Judge Oka Says Judges Are Targeted Over Environmental Orders, Calls Sanyal’s Broad Claim Unconstructive

He says criticism of the judiciary must cite specific orders to be meaningful.

Overview

  • Speaking at a Supreme Court Bar Association event on Oct. 29, Abhay S. Oka said judges who issue strong environmental rulings are being targeted.
  • He criticized Sanjeev Sanyal’s assertion that courts hinder “Viksit Bharat,” saying such a claim needs examples of particular orders to qualify as constructive critique.
  • Oka said citizens who bring environmental cases face ridicule and are branded anti‑development, discouraging public interest litigation.
  • He argued courts must not be swayed by popular or religious sentiment, adding that firecrackers, idol immersions and loudspeakers are not essential religious practices and that no faith permits pollution.
  • Oka urged strict enforcement of environmental laws with public participation and political support, noting a visible pollution layer over Delhi and warning other cities, including Mumbai, face comparable risks.