Florida Kayak Guide Charged with Murder After Woman Found Dead in Resort Room

Dylan Lamb is accused of killing Nadyne Marie Tillman and concealing her body in a Key Largo hotel room, with evidence tampering complicating the investigation.

Nadyne Marie Tillman, 43, was found dead in a closet at the Amoray Dive Resort in Key Largo on Monday, days after being reported missing by her family.
Dylan Lamb, 33, a local kayak guide, was arrested Tuesday and charged with second-degree murder, evidence tampering, kidnapping, and soliciting prostitution.
Investigators revealed that hotel staff discarded bloodied linens from Lamb's room without notifying law enforcement, potentially hindering evidence collection.
New guests unknowingly stayed in the room where Tillman’s body was concealed, raising serious questions about hotel safety and procedural lapses.
Lamb allegedly admitted to striking Tillman during an altercation and attempting to cover up her death by cleaning the scene and hiding her body.