Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Florence Court of Appeal Orders Pisa University Hospital to Pay €470,000 for False Cancer Diagnosis

An independent court-appointed expert found no evidence for the lymphoma diagnosis that drove years of unnecessary treatment.

Overview

  • The ruling raises the initial award of €295,000 and increases the permanent disability rating from 40% to 60%.
  • Court documents state the woman underwent about four years of chemotherapy, corticosteroids, and other drugs after a MALT lymphoma diagnosis made in Pisa.
  • A second opinion in Genoa in 2011, supported by new biopsies, concluded she did not have cancer.
  • Judges recognized lasting physical harm, psychological distress, and work setbacks, including a period when she lost her driving license.
  • The University Hospital of Pisa maintained the case was clinically complex, but the appellate court rejected that defense based on the expert assessment.